People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This Atlanta pizza shop is cute and has pretty good pizza! We went for a little family lunch and ordered a pizza with ground beef. What came out looked like sausage, not ground beef, but it reminded me of the school pizzas I loved as a kid! We ordered to-go so I can't really speak to the service. We just grabbed a pizza and left, but the staff seemed friendly when we ordered! ”
“ Vinnys is New York style pizza to perfection! Used to live in midtown and walk to pick it up and everyone is so nice here. Now ubereats it to our place one of our favorite pizzas in town! ”
“ Absolutely delicious and the perfect taste of sauce,cheese and crunch of the undercarriage of the slice. We met Shane and being from NJ I brought my family in from Canada and my kid and mom and we devoured all of the food. It's the best I've had since NY and NJ. The calzone was delicious...the white slice was amazing and I highly recommend and I love it so much I'm buying 2 pies on Saturday to drive back to augusta. They give a military discount as well. Great spot.great service ”
“ Years ago, Vinny's was questionable. Today, Vinny's is an institution that sustains Midtown. The staff is friendly. The food is great! Not exotic, Just fantastic with the staples. My biggest problem: they close at pre-Batman hours. I always order to go and I can't emphasize enough how amazing the staff is. But I wish they stayed open later. They get 5 stars and I wish I could give them six. ”
“ Great slices and they're cheap. Ordered a whole pizza the second time and it was good but a lil bit too greedy for me and I like cheesy greedy pizza. Definitely go again. ”
“ As a native New Yorker I can confirm that the pizza at this location (860 Peachtree St., Midtown, GA) tastes exactly like NY pizza! First bite took me back to BKNY!! ”
“ We hit Vinny's New York Pizza recently before a show at the Fox Theatre, with my son and his uncle. As a native New Yorker I'm always keen to try NY pizza in Atlanta... good news and not-so-good news on that front. Staff was SUPER friendly and kind, which is always appreciated and refreshing. The place looked like a hippster, NYC dive-joint, which was, to me, also on point. The pizza itself, although quite tasty and enjoyable, wasn't really evocative of New York--sauce was a bit too sweet and the dough wasn't thin enough. NYC 'za is foldable goodness with zingy tomato sauce, and Vinny's was thicker than average. on a brighter note, Uncle and I had a side salad, which was surprisingly good! we had the balsamic dressing and I would order that again in a heartbeat. thanks for a fun time and good food! ”
“ Last minute dinner and most places we usually order from were closed, thank goodness! Meatballs were a great value, delicious, and made me happy dance. Pizza was perfect and love the crust crunch. Will definitely order again. ”
Menu
16" NY Pizza Sicilian
$24.0016" NY Pizza
$21.60Works
$19.00Veggie
$19.00Meat O Mania
$19.00
About
Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown
Welcome to Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown, a celebrated gem nestled in the heart of Atlanta at 860 Peachtree St NE. Specializing in authentic New York-style pizzas and hearty Italian dishes, Vinny's combines classic flavors with a warm, inviting atmosphere that is perfect for gatherings with family and friends.
From the moment you step inside, you'll be greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. Whether you're indulging in a casual lunch or a cozy dinner, Vinny's offers a delightful menu that caters to all cravings. Their offerings aren't just delicious—they're a true culinary experience:
- Pizza: Choose from an array of sizes, including the 10" gluten-free crust or the generous 16" NY pizza, loaded with homemade sauce and quality whole milk mozzarella. The specialty pizzas, like the White Pizza and Vinny's Special, are customer favorites, packing a punch of flavor that keeps patrons coming back for more.
- Strombolis: If pizza is not on your mind, try their build-your-own or meat and veggie strombolis. Each bite is a melty, cheesy delight, satisfying even the heartiest of appetites.
But it's not just about the food; the experience at Vinny's is just as noteworthy. Many patrons rave about the friendly staff and the vibrant atmosphere. Customer reviews highlight the casual dress code, making it a laid-back spot where good food and laughter blend seamlessly. Free Wi-Fi and outdoor seating options further enhance your visit, making it an ideal location for groups and families.
Aside from the delightful menu, Vinny's offers catering services, perfect for those special occasions, whether it’s a birthday or a corporate event. Plus, with the convenience of delivery, takeout, and acceptance of various payment methods including Android Pay and Apple Pay, your pizza cravings are just a few clicks away.
Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub where the love for pizza and good company come together. With reviews praising everything from the classic NY flavors to the friendly service, it’s no wonder this spot has become a beloved institution in Midtown. For a taste of New York without leaving Atlanta, make sure to stop by or order some pies to go—your taste buds will thank you!
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at (404) 872-0484.
Book a table